Korea Fair Trade Commission’s Increased Litigation Budget Sparks Controversy

Seoul:The Korea Fair Trade Commission's (KFTC) request to increase its litigation budget has ignited a debate at the National Assembly's Special Committee on Budget and Accounts. The commission has sought 5.1 billion won (approximately US$3.84 million) for the upcoming year's litigation costs, marking a 34 percent increase from this year's budget of 3.8 billion won.

According to Yonhap News Agency, the committee's senior expert adviser suggested a reduction of 1.1 billion won from the proposed budget. However, the KFTC maintained that the full amount was necessary. The commission is responsible for imposing fines on companies for unfair practices such as collusion, which often leads to administrative lawsuits and subsequent litigation expenses.

This year, the commission imposed over 4 trillion won in fines across six major price-fixing cases, including those related to government bonds and flour. The fines have more than doubled compared to the 1.97 trillion won imposed between 2022 and 2024. The first half of this year alone saw fines totaling 1.75 trillion won, significantly higher than last year's total.

In a notable case, the KFTC fined 15 financial institutions a record 1.62 trillion won for government bond bidding-rigging. The institutions have announced plans to contest the penalties in court. Additionally, the commission imposed 1.81 trillion won in fines for price-fixing in sugar, flour, and starch syrup markets.

Disputes over fine calculations have been common, as seen in the case of food delivery platforms Baemin and Coupang Eats, which were fined over 600 billion won for allegedly abusing market dominance. Coupang Eats was fined 300.8 billion won, significantly higher than initial estimates.

Companies have been successful in reducing fines through legal challenges. For instance, the Seoul High Court overturned a 234.9 billion won fine against Samsung affiliates, and the Supreme Court canceled a portion of a fine against Hoban Construction. Since 2021, KFTC has refunded 191.7 billion won in fines, with taxpayers covering the interest on these refunds.

Rep. Song Eon-seok of the People Power Party highlighted that the rate at which courts suspend KFTC sanctions has increased, reaching 79.5 percent by September this year. Companies face significant costs contesting these fines, and when the government loses, it incurs additional interest payments on refunds, straining the state treasury.

The KFTC is under scrutiny for its handling of fines, with critics suggesting that excessive penalties benefit law firms employing former commission officials. The commission has been urged to develop a fair and accepted framework for calculating fines and to avoid imposing excessive penalties that are likely to be contested in court.

Source Yonhap News Agency